| Champion Spalding Chase | 1890 |
| Thomas I. Creigh | 1891 |
| William Wallace Copeland | 1892 |
| Peter L. Perine | 1893 |
| Aurelius Bowen | 1894 |
| Rev. Luther M. Kuhns | 1895 |
| Lucius D. Richards | 1897 |
| John R. Webster | 1898 |
| Fred W. Vaughn | 1899 |
| Horace Ludington | 1900 |
| John H. Daniels | 1901 |
| L. P. Funkhouser | 1902 |
| John W. Battin | 1903-1904 |
| Amos Field | 1905 |
| Irving S. Cutter | 1906 |
| James H. Adams | 1907 |
| Ralph W. Breckenridge | 1908-1909 |
| Pressley J. Barr | 1910-1912 |
| J. F. Flack | 1913 |
| George L. Loomis | 1914 |
| Frederick H. Richards | 1915 |
| Herbert M. Bushnell | 1916 |
| C. J. Bowlby | 1917 |
| C. E. Adams | 1918 |
| Benjamin F. Bailey | 1919-1923 |
| Col. J. M. Banister | 1924 |
| N. C. Abbott | 1925 |
| N. C. Abbott | 1926 |
| N. B. Updike | 1927 |
| A. L. Bixby | 1928 |
| Benjamin F. Bailey | 1929 |
| Dr. J. J. Snipes | 1930 |
| Dr. F. A. Stuff | 1931 |
| Dr. J. J. Snipes | 1932 |
| David C. Hilton | 1933 |
| Smith C. Wilson | 1934 |
| Walton B. Roberts | 1935 |
| Fred Eastman | 1936 |
| Sterling Fann Mutz | 1937-1938 |
| Vivian W. Boyles | 1939 |
| Charles L. Taylor | 1940 |
| Dr. C. F. Hollenbeck | 1941 |
| Harry W. Meginnis | 1942 |
| Addison E. Sheldon | 1943-1944 |
| Frederick L. Wolfe | 1945 |
| Harold D. LeMar | 1946 |
| Henry M. Cox | 1947 |
| Howard A. Chapin | 1948 |
| Merle M. Hale | 1949 |
| Edson Smith | 1950-1951 |
| George N. Mecham | 1952 |
| L. R. King | 1953 |
| Louis Shirk | 1954 |
| R. D. Neely | 1955 |
| Charles W. Hill | 1956 |
| Ralph S. Moseley | 1957 |
| Lynn G. Barnes | 1958 |
| Harmon M Turner | 1959 |
| Robert D. Cresap | 1960 |
| E. Forrest Estes | 1960-1961 |
| Ferman E. Borchers | 1961-1962 |
| Rev Carl Davidson | 1962-1963 |
| Rev Earle Conover | 1964-1965 |
| Harold C. Elliot | 1965-1966 |
| Frank H. Binder | 1966 |
| Clarence R. Hatten | 1966-1967 |
| De Los Hopkins | 1967-1968 |
| Harold B. Muffly | 1968-1969 |
| Royce N. Kent | 1970-1971 |
| Doane T. Pickering | 1970-1971 |
| David P. Greer | 1972 |
| Hubert R. Mann | 1972-1973 |
| Wallace G. Quest | 1974-1975 |
| Neal Chisum | 1975-1976 |
| Royce N. Kent | 1976-1977 |
| Heasty W. Reesman | 1978-1979 |
| Worthington Fowler | 1980-1981 |
| Donald Miltner | 1982-1983 |
| Wallace C. Quest | 1984-1985 |
| Thomas R Creigh Jr. | 1986-1987 |
| Dayle K. Purcell | 1988-1989 |
| David Mickey | 1990-1991 |
| Donald C. Classen | 1992-1993 |
| Thomas R. Masters | 1994-1995 |
| Richard H. Burdick | 1996-1997 |
| Byron A. Warlick | 1998-1999 |
| R. James Denney | 2000-2001 |
| John W. Reinert | 2002-2003 |
| John T. Parsons | 2004-2005 |
| Merle A. Rudebusch | 2006-2007 |
| CMSgt (ret)Robert L. Knott | 2008-2009 |
| LaVerne E. Stetson | 2010-2011 |
| Frederick A. Walden | 2012-2013 |
| John Reinert | 2014-2015 |
| Dr. David Kentsmith | 2016-2017 |
| William Webb | 2018 |
| Shawn K. Stoner | 2018-2019 |